SCL Construction Law Essay Prize Competition 2026

Failed to load licensing components. Please Repair / Re-Install Dixit . DO NOT UNINSTALL MODULE!

Congratulations to our Society of Construction Law 2026 Essay Prize Winners

Essays published in our members only area



First Place: Nate Wain

Proportionate Liability, Disproportionate Risk for Homeowners: A Catalyst for a Statutory Duty of Care for Defective Residential Building Work in New Zealand
The Judges citation:
A meticulously researched and timely analysis of the risks associated with the proportionate liability regime currently reforming the Building Act. The author suggests well-considered safeguards for vulnerable homeowners.  The essay is distinguished by its comparative analysis of frameworks from the United Kingdom and New South Wales; thought-provoking perspectives to add to the National discourse on this subject ahead of the upcoming regime shift.

 

Second Place: Amanda Joshua

How to train your expert: A proposal for independent expert appointments in construction disputes
The Judges citation:
 A comprehensive, well-researched assessment of limitations of the expert witness function in construction disputes, with pragmatic analysis of international practices and a bold reform proposal.  Especially pertinent as construction disputes increasingly become ‘battles between experts’, with parties, their lawyers and decision-makers often inundated by huge volumes of highly technical evidence.

 

Third Place – Recommended for Publication: Oscar Read and Ria Shon

for their joint essay titled
Pay Now, Agree to Disagree: Final Offer Adjudication and the Algorithm of Agreement

 

Recommended for Publication: Laura Canton

Public Private Partnerships in Aotearoa New Zealand – Promise or Problem?


Save these dates for when our 1st and 2nd prize winners will be presenting their essays 
Christchurch Tues 28 July
Wellington Wed 29 July
Auckland Thurs 30 July
registration opening soon

Most recent meetings

May & 4 June Aklnd 2026

Tailoring or Tampering? The Hidden Costs of Special Conditions in Construction

David Wilkie and Mike Hanson

photo: Mike Hanson standing, David Wilkie sitting RHS

Flyer |   recording (courtesy of Reflective Construction Law), powerpoint and CPD register in Members Only Area

21 May 2026

The ongoing Middle East conflict (MEC-26) and global fuel & freight disruptions: considerations for NZ construction contracts

Hamish Bolland and Lawrie Saegers

 

Flyer |   webinar recording (courtesy of Chapman Tripp), powerpoint and CPD register in Members Only Area

ABOUT THE NEW ZEALAND SOCIETY OF CONSTRUCTION LAW

The New Zealand Society of Construction Law was formed in 2005 to promote research and education in the field of construction law and a means by which people from throughout the industry could come together to discuss issues relating to construction law.
SCL is an interest group not a professional institute.  Evidence of professional qualification is not required.

The Society reached the milestone of having 1000 members in November 2023 heralding from all sectors of the construction industry, including:
  • lawyers
  • architects
  • engineers
  • quantity surveyors
  • contractors
  • project managers
  • insurers
  • academics

BRANCH MEETINGS

The Society meets regularly for presentations by speakers, and these meetings also provide an opportunity for informal networking. Meetings are usually held monthly in:
 
  • Auckland
  • Wellington
  • Christchurch
with one of the sessions being livestreamed.  We usually host 'in-person hubs' in Hamilton, Dunedin and Queenstown for members to have the opportunity to network. We endeavour to a host an in-person meeting in Hamilton and Dunedin during the year if possible.

There is no cost to members to attend these meetings. 

Copies of presentations, papers and the recorded sessions presented at these meetings are available to members in the 'Members Only' section of the website.

Upcoming Meetings

2026 Essay Prize Winners presentating their essays

a highlight on the SCL calendar

Nate Wain (First Place) and Amanda Joshua (Second Place)

presenting their essays

Registration opening soon
Christchurch Tues 28 July
Wellington Wed 29 July
Auckland Thurs 30 July

Now in Members Only Area

visit members only for recordings, ppts and CPD

8 July 2026, webinar

The Building Amendment Bill 2026

An Analysis of New Zealand's Proposed Building Liability Reforms Following the Introduction of the Bill into Parliament

Adjunct Professor Kim Lovegrove

Helen Macfarlane, moderator

Flyer introducing our speaker & discussion

 

May Meeting (4 June Aklnd)

Tailoring or Tampering? The Hidden Costs of Special Conditions in Construction

Mike Hanson and David Wilkie

 

21 May 2026 lunchtime webinar

The ongoing Middle East conflict (MEC-26) and global fuel & freight disruptions: considerations for NZ construction contracts

Hamish Bolland and Lawrie Saegers, moderated by Jonathan Aquilina

Flyer

 

April

Adjudicator jurisdiction across jurisdictions

Janine Stewart and Rebecca Cook

Flyer | 

 

 

16 April lunchtime webinar

construction law caselaw update

Lily Kennedy-Perkins Galbraith v Global Metal Solutions Ltd [2026] NZHC 382

Matthew Ferrier Body Corporate 406198 v Argon Construction [2025] NZCA 684

Caleb Smith 𝘕𝘦𝘭𝘴𝘰𝘯 𝘷 𝘕𝘰𝘰𝘬 𝘏𝘰𝘮𝘦𝘴 𝘓𝘵𝘥 [2026] NZHC 233

Flyer

 

March 2026

Be flexible. Be innovative. Be competitive. Be insured? 
(AKA a surprising thing happened during my recent visit to Punxsutawney)

Dave Barr

 

12 February 2026

construction law caselaw updates

Stuart Robertson, Brendan Cash and Jonathan Forsey

Discussed cases that covered retentions and their status in a liquidation. Termination for delay and defects and whether the director of the builder could also be held personally liable and “An Expert Horror Story”.

Recording (courtesy of Duncan Cotterill), the cases to download (see flyer) and CPD record sheet in Members Only Area

 

2025 Members Only Area

2024 Members Only Area

2023 Members Only Area 

2022 Members Only Area

2021 Members Only Area

2020 Members Only Area

2019 Members Only Area

 

Congratulations 2025 Essay Prize Winners

 

First Place:  Oscar Read

Preconditions to Arbitration: Supporting Best-For-Project Dispute Resolution

 

Second Place: Erica Dysart

Judge, Jury, and Executioner – Extending Self-Certification Abilities to Trusted Building Practitioners


Our prizewinning essays will be published in our Members Only Area shortly

New Members Welcome

The Society welcomes new members

Visit our Become a Member page for membership benefits, application form and subscription information

 

 

New SCL(Intl) papers are continually added to the SCL International website

SLC(NZ) members can access these papers on the SCL(Intl) website

 

Need help accessing the members area of SLC(Intl)? 

Contact SCL(NZ) Manager Melanie Whittaker

 

WORLDWIDE CONNECTIONS

The New Zealand Society maintains ties with its sister societies in other parts of the world so that members are kept up-to-date about news and upcoming events in the construction industry in those jurisdictions.

New Zealand members have access to papers published on the SCL(International) website.

2019 SCL Fundamentals of Construction Law – the project lifecycle Conference

2019 conference delegates

2017 SCL Wellington Transmission Gully site tour

Transmission Gully site visit 

2015 Christchurch Key Projects in the Christchurch City Rebuild tour

Christchurch Town Hall site visit 

 

2019 conference delegates

2017 SCL Wellington Transmission Gully site tour

Transmission Gully site visit 

SCL 2015 Christchurch city tour participants

The Christchurch Justice and Emergency Services Precinct site visit

SCL(NZ) HOSTS A BIENNIAL CONFERENCE

 

2021: SCL(NZ) was proud to host the 9th International Society of Construction Law 'Building for Change' Conference

4-5 November 2021

Virtual (due to Covid-19 restrictions international and domestic NZ travel was prohibited), Auckland, New Zealand

9th International Conference Papers and recording

 

2019: Fundamentals of Construction Law – the project lifecycle - Auckland conference papers

23 July 2019 (preceded by SCL AGM)

Level 5 Lounge, North Stand, Eden Park, Auckland.

This conference covered themed project lifecycle stages of a construction project, from procurement, insurance, performance, to termination and resolving disputes.

2017: Identifying and Managing Obligations, Wellington - Wellington conference papers

15 June 2017: Site Tour - Transmission Gully

16 June 2017:  Conference at Te Papa, Wellington (keynote Richard Wilmot-Smith QC of 39 Essex Chambers, London)

2015 : Best Practice Procurement and Contracting in NZ Construction & Infrastructure - Christchurch conference papers

13 August 2015 : City Tour- Key Projects in the Christchurch City Rebuild (photos above)

14 August 2015 : Conference at The Chateau on the Park (photos below)

2014 : When the Contract Gets Dirty – applying the contract to on-site reality - Auckland conference papers

2012 : Construction Law Core Skills Seminar, Fundamental Topics in Construction Law presented by Leading Industry Practitioners - Auckland conference papers

 

2019 SCL Fundamentals of Construction Law – the project lifecycle Conference - Auckland

2017 Identifying and Managing Obligations - Wellington

2015 Best Practice Procurement and Contracting in NZ Construction & Infrastructure Conference - Christchurch